The Leaving
 Book cover | |
| Author | Jumi Bello |
|---|---|
| Language | English |
| Genre | Literary fiction |
| Publication place | United States |
The Leaving is a novel by Jumi Bello. In 2022, the novel was canceled by its publisher Riverhead Books prior to release after Bello revealed that much of the book was plagiarized.[1]
Background
[edit]Bello is the daughter of a Haitian American mother and a Nigerian father. After graduating from Grinnell College in 2013, she lived and traveled widely in Asia, including China, Taiwan, and the Philippines. Bello graduated from the Master of Fine Arts program in creative writing at the Iowa Writers' Workshop in 2021. In April 2021, she sold The Leaving, her debut novel, to publisher Riverhead Books in a six-figure deal.[2]
Plot
[edit]Sumatra, a young black woman with a dissociative disorder living in Beijing, learns that she is pregnant and returns to the United States. She recounts her troubled and traumatic life story in a series of flashbacks, therapy sessions, and recordings for her unborn daughter.[2][3]
Reception
[edit]Before its release, The Leaving received a positive blurb from author Lidia Yuknavitch, who described the book as "nothing short of thrilling." Powell's Books called it "a wise and searching novel... emotionally cataclysmic yet ultimately hopeful, rendered in lyrical, spellbinding prose".[3] The novel had also appeared on multiple lists of the "most anticipated" books of 2022.[4]
Plagiarism issues
[edit]According to Bello, in December 2021 she informed her editor that the manuscript of The Leaving contained passages taken from authors James Baldwin and Carole Maso. In response, Riverhead Books conducted a thorough review of the manuscript, identifying roughly 30 separate instances of plagiarism. The full list of authors whom Bello had plagiarized included Baldwin, Maso, Marie Cardinal, Matthew Olzmann, Jennifer Nansubuga Makumbi, Rebecca Solnit, and Bassey Ikpi. Riverhead estimated that 30 percent of The Leaving's contents were plagiarized.[2]
The novel's publication, which had been scheduled for July 2022, was canceled by Riverhead in February.[5] In May, Bello published an essay on the website Literary Hub admitting to the plagiarism amid her struggles with mental illness and the pressure she felt to publish. Bello claimed that she had searched for other writers' depictions of pregnancy online, since she had never been pregnant herself, and had initially justified it to herself as "just borrowing and changing the language."[1] She also claimed that Riverhead had reduced her time to edit the manuscript from eight months to two months.[2]
Literary Hub withdrew Bello's essay hours after its publication. Readers discovered that the essay, too, had been plagiarized, with material taken from an article on the history of plagiarism from the website Plagiarism Today. In a statement, Literary Hub said that the essay had been removed "because of inconsistencies in the story and, crucially, a further incident of plagiarism in the published piece".[1] Jonathan Bailey, author of the plagiarized article, called Bello's writing process "a deeply problematic approach" that "makes plagiarism not only likely, but inevitable... The way you avoid plagiarism isn’t to 'change the language' but to never have that language in your original work in the first place."[1][6]
Many social media users noted the irony in Bello having plagiarized in an essay meant to atone for her plagiarism. Writers such as Akwaeke Emezi and Terese Marie Mailhot defended Bello, arguing that she was receiving heightened criticism because of her race. Bello disagreed with these claims, but suggested that her identity as a black woman contributed to the media's interest in the story. Roxane Gay also expressed her support for Bello on Twitter, hoping that there would be "a space for redemption at some point".[2]
A July 2022 Air Mail article extensively profiled Bello and the controversy surrounding The Leaving. In the article, Bello disclosed that she had schizoaffective disorder and post-traumatic stress disorder, and that she had been involuntarily hospitalized after graduating from Iowa, signing her book's contract the day after her release. The article also revealed that Bello had been involved in two previous plagiarism controversies: a poetry slam competition in Beijing, in which she plagiarized the poem "dogs!" by Danez Smith; and a submission to her fiction workshop at Iowa, in which she plagiarized a passage from Carmen Maria Machado's short story "Inventory." Bello apologized for her actions, saying that she had "made mistakes" and "hurt people terribly" while struggling with psychiatric treatment, external pressures, and life events.[2]
References
[edit]- ^ a b c d Victor, Daniel (May 10, 2022). "Her Novel Was Pulled for Plagiarism. Her Explanation Was, Too". The New York Times. Archived from the original on March 14, 2023. Retrieved January 4, 2024.
- ^ a b c d e f Berkman, Johanna (July 23, 2022). "Jumi Bello, Literary Star Brought Down by Plagiarism Scandal, Tells Her Story – Air Mail". Air Mail. Archived from the original on April 26, 2023. Retrieved January 4, 2024.
- ^ a b "The Leaving: Jumi Bello: : 9780593538876: Powell's Books". Powell's Books. Archived from the original on May 9, 2022. Retrieved January 4, 2024.
- ^ Whiting, Amanda (May 10, 2022). "Jumi Bello: Author's essay about plagiarism retracted after allegations of additional plagiarism". The Independent. Archived from the original on September 8, 2022. Retrieved January 4, 2024.
- ^ Italie, Hillel (May 9, 2022). "Author's plagiarism essay pulled after more plagiarism found". Associated Press. Archived from the original on November 28, 2023. Retrieved January 4, 2024.
- ^ Bailey, Jonathan (May 9, 2022). "Plagiarism Today Plagiarized in a Plagiarism Atonement Essay". Plagiarism Today. Archived from the original on December 11, 2023. Retrieved January 4, 2024.